Reed Cooper News
  • Breaking News
  • Store
  • NEWSLETTER
  • CONTACT
  • ABOUT US
    • Gene Van Shaar

DERSHOWITZ: TARGETING TRUMP'S LAWYER SHOULD WORRY US ALL

4/11/2018

Comments

 
Picture
  Alan Dershowits wrote on The Hill, "There is much speculation as to the significance of the search of the offices and hotel room of President Trump’s lawyer, Michael Cohen. To obtain a search warrant, prosecutors must demonstrate to a judge that they have probable cause to believe that the premises to be searched contain evidence of crime. They must also specify the area to be searched, the items to be seized and, in searches of computers, the word searches to be used.

   At least that’s the constitutional requirement in theory, especially where the Sixth Amendment right to counsel is involved, in addition to the general Fourth Amendment right against unreasonable searches. Yet, in practice, judges often give the FBI considerable latitude, relying on the “firewalls” and “taint teams” they set up to protect the subject of the search from violation of his or her constitutional rights.

   But the firewalls and taint teams are comprised of government agents who themselves may not be entitled to read or review many of the items seized. It is an imperfect protection of important constitutional rights. That’s why Justice Department officials must be careful to limit the searching of lawyers’ offices to compelling cases involving serious crimes. We don’t know at this point what the prosecutors are looking for but, if it relates to payments made to porn star Stormy Daniels, that would not seem to justify so potentially intrusive a search of Cohen’s confidential lawyer-client files.

​    There are, of course, exceptions to the lawyer-client privilege. First, the lawyer must be acting as a lawyer, not as a friend or business associate. But the scope of a lawyer’s work is quite broad, encompassing much more than merely giving legal advice. It includes settling cases by making payments to potential litigants. Second, the lawyer must be engaged in lawful activities on behalf of the clients. Illegal or fraudulent activities are not covered by the privilege. Nor are communications with third persons, such as the lawyer for the other side, though such communications may be covered by the much weaker “settlement privilege.”

    Civil libertarians should be concerned whenever the government interferes with the lawyer-client relationship. Clients should be able to rely on confidentiality when they disclose their most intimate secrets in an effort to secure their legal rights. A highly publicized raid on the president’s lawyer will surely shake the confidence of many clients in promises of confidentiality by their lawyers. They will not necessarily understand the nuances of the confidentiality rules and their exceptions. They will see a lawyer’s office being raided and all his files seized.

   I believe we would have been hearing more from civil libertarians — the American Civil Liberties Union, attorney groups and privacy advocates — if the raid had been on Hillary Clinton’s lawyer. Many civil libertarians have remained silent about potential violations of President Trump’s rights because they strongly disapprove of him and his policies. That is a serious mistake, because these violations establish precedents that lie around like loaded guns capable of being aimed at other targets.

   I have been widely attacked for defending the constitutional rights of a president I voted against. In our hyper-partisan age, everyone is expected to choose a side, either for or against Trump. But the essence of civil liberties is that they must be equally applicable to all. The silence among most civil libertarians regarding the recent raid shows that we are losing that valuable neutrality."
Comments
comments powered by Disqus
    America's Source of Pro-Trump News

    Reed Cooper
    Picture
    Reed Cooper is a seventeen-year-old die-hard supporter of President Donald Trump and has supported him since day one. Reed wears Trump shirts everyday and has for the past five years. He is the author of all news articles on "Reed Cooper News."

    Contact Us
    Submit

    SHOP

    Trump "Keep America Great" Cap - FREE SHIPPING

    $20.00 $15.00

    FREE SHIPPING ONLY IN US!


    Show off your patriotism by wearing BEST President Trump's new icon featuring the new "Keep America Great" slogan and a American flag on the side.

    • Keep America Great hand-stitched
    • American flag hand-stiched
    • One size fits most
    • Premium SnapBack cap with rope across the bill
    • 100% high-quality cotton
    Shop

    5 Trump Keep America Great 2020 Bumper Sticker

    $12.50 $10.00

    FREE SHIPPING ONLY IN US!

    Trump 2020 bumper sticker perfect for any pro-Trump friend or family.

    • Made With High Quality Vinyl To Last
    • Easy on Peel and Stick Easy Off Quality Durable Vinyl Decals For Your Front or Rear Bumper
    Shop

FOLLOW US ON SOCIAL MEDIA

© COPYRIGHT 2021 — REED COOPER NEWS. ALL RIGHTS RESERVED.
Photo used under Creative Commons from Gage Skidmore
  • Breaking News
  • Store
  • NEWSLETTER
  • CONTACT
  • ABOUT US
    • Gene Van Shaar